The "New" West Essay

1022 words - 5 pages

In his book, The Life and Adventures of Joaquín Murieta, author John Rollin Ridge introduces readers to a fictional character, who is a larger-than-life bandit. According to the story, Murieta set out on a path of revenge and organized a large band of outlaws to terrorize Californians. Murieta and his men committed terrible and bloody crimes (including robbery and murder). This pattern of criminal behavior continued until the band was pursued by mountain rangers, ending the story in a dramatic climax for the protagonist. However, this story is not an accurate depiction of the important elements of the “New” West according to author Patricia Nelson Limerick, in The Legacy of Conquest: The Unbroken Past of the American West. Instead, the character Murieta exemplifies many of the myths of the American West and the idea of innocence.
In her book, Limerick describes the “idea of innocence” that permeated the American West (36). According to the author, the underlying motive for every action was pure (even when it really was not). According to Western American folklore, early settlers did intend to victimize Indians and trespass on their land, but instead came to America to pursue new opportunities and improve their lives (Limerick 36). The same ideological theory may be applied to the motivations of the sensationalized outlaws from the time. For example, in her book Limerick details the life of John Wesley Hardin, an outlaw, who began his violent life of crime at the age of fifteen (36). According to the story, Hardin shot and killed a black man (Limerick 36). However, idolized as the son of a preacher, Hardin hid his crimes behind the veils of “bravery” and “honor” (Limerick 36). He claimed that he actually shot the man -- a bully -- in self-defense (Limerick 36). Hardin held himself out to be an innocent victim of social injustice, as opposed to a blood-thirsty killer of twenty plus men (Limerick 37). Even in jail, Hardin reportedly read scripture and lead a bible study group (Limerick 36). He defended his crimes because they were committed against those who he viewed as “[subjugators] of the South (Limerick 37). This characterization of the Western outlaw is strikingly similar to Ridge’s fictional outlaw, Joaquín Murieta.
Much like Hardin, Murieta was celebrated for being a model citizen, well-versed in the bible and theology. Also like Hardin, Murieta was the son of “respectable” parents and was well-educated (Ridge 8). According to Ridge, he was noble, generous and well-liked by everyone (8). The author also describes Murieta as being physically attractive, increasing his overall appeal to the reader (Ridge 9). Further paralleling Hardin, Murieta’s life of crime resulted from an oppression, after being victimized by a group of “lawless men” (Ridge 10). Murieta was beaten, tied up, his mistress was raped, his half-brother was framed and then killed, and Murieta was tied to a tree and beaten again (Ridge 10-12). Following the...

Find Another Essay On The "New" West

Turners Frontier Thesis Essay

1021 words - 5 pages cultural similarities one can determine which areas would be considered the “true” West. The majority of responses indicated that the ideal West includes: Montana, Wyoming, Idaho, Colorado, New Mexico, Arizona, Nevada, Utah, Oregon, and Washington – California is not included. From this range, it is safe to say that the majority of readers recognized that the culture of the West is identified by presence of cattle. This is also perpetuated by the

New German Cinema Essay

1169 words - 5 pages New German Cinema Introduction The Second World War brought forth not only physical destruction to Germany, but also cultural destruction, particularly in its film industry. The film industry of West Germany, in particular, went under the inevitable control of the United States (US). American films became popular among the West German public, while prominent West German directors and actors chose to leave West Germany to pursue their careers

Key West

982 words - 4 pages something had to be done. Julius Stone, director of the Florida FERA, led a nation wide campaign proclaiming that Key West was Americas new tropical paradise and it worked(Gifford 13). The tourism industry built up soon after that and Key West was successful again. Still today, tourism remains Key West's largest industry. It is home to the only living coral reef in North America and it takes pride in managing and protecting that vital

The Undeniable Influence of Kanye West

1719 words - 7 pages music we listen to on this very day? West came onto the scene in the late nineties but didn’t release The College Dropout until 2004, an album that took everybody by surprise. Kanye West changed the gangster filled rap genre by releasing his positive, soulful debut album, changing the way rappers dress, and paving the way for a whole new style of introspective lyrics and soul-inspired rap production in the mainstream. When West first showed up

Robert Lee “Sam” Huff and West Virginia

938 words - 4 pages West Virginia is stereotyped as a poor state, a state that suffers badly from poverty. Most people fail to see the positive things about West Virginia, such as their beautiful environment that allows great vacation places that are always neglected along with minerals and goods that are produced throughout the United States of America and used worldwide. Although, West Virginia is stereotyped as a poverty based state, it has much to offer. A

The american west

548 words - 2 pages came into the west because of the ever so generous Homestead Act which allowed settler to get around 160 acres of land while improving the land and paying 30 dollars. Or they could pay 1.25 an acre when the land is gotten only after 6 months of living there. This enabled the farmers to settle in the once barren areas of the West. With these new found land, farmers used methods of "dry farming" to adapt to the droughts when growing their crops

Imagination in Cornel West's Race Matters: The First Step Towards Restoring Hope to the Nihilistic African-American Community

1381 words - 6 pages black community. He calls for the admission "that the most valuable sources for help, hope, and power consist of ourselves and our common history," for black Americans to "focus [...] attention on the public square," and for the "need to generate new leadership" (West, 11-12). West does not specifically delineate the exact process by which these goals should be achieved. Instead, he intentionally only issues general and basic outlines of what

A Tale of Two Germanies

805 words - 4 pages Germany because the country was rapidly modernizing with the surplus of ideas about new ways the nation could improve. Not only was West Berlin able to develop faster than East Berlin because of the governmental conditions, but culture also had a big impact on how fast each side developed. The people living in West Germany were much more diverse due to the variety of rock and pop culture that was influenced by the United States. By using radios and

The Rise of the West

1449 words - 6 pages the West occurred mainly because of European’s innovative culture after 1000 C.E. that led it to transform world power during the Industrial Revoltion. (pg.4) Landes’ argument that innovative minds of Europe helped in creating the superpower of Western Europe indeed has merit. It is because of people who think innovatively can new inventions or culture changes take place. It is also because of inventions and culture changes that societies rise in

The Ode to West Wind, by Percy Bysshe Shelley

1479 words - 6 pages hill (Line) Seeds are "winged" in such a way that they are able to prosper and fly; on the other hand, those seeds are restrained inside their graves, which implies seeds are new hopes or new concepts but they are week under the old ages. In this way, the west wind is the revolutionist in autumn while the spring would represent a new era where new hopes and concepts prevail so "sweet buds" will fill the "dreaming earth" which is "under the

Voices from the Past in Stephen Crane's The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky

1259 words - 5 pages dramatize how civilization that has begun to invade Yellow Sky. The drummer is an outsider to Yellow Sky, yet he has influence on the town; as a traveling salesman, he is a part of the new business economy that is changing Yellow Sky. The bartender is a businessman, too, a representative of one of the first businesses to take root in the Old West. But newer businesses serviced by the drummer are coming to Yellow Sky and changing it. Perhaps the

Similar Essays

Spaces Of The New American West

1308 words - 6 pages travel to California, widely considered to be the epicenter of growth and modernization in the States. With Silicon Valley and Yellowstone all in one region, there is a unique sense of space presented within the West that is unattainable from the American North, East, or South. For instance, a trip to New York City may be fairly comparable to a trip to Pittsburgh, but a trip to San Francisco as opposed to Rapid City provides an entirely different

Will Eastern Europe Become The New Periphery To The Prosperous Nations Of The West?

2663 words - 11 pages Will Eastern Europe become the New Periphery to the Prosperous Nations of the West? "Enlargement is one the most important opportunities for the European Union as it prepares for the 21st century. It is a unique, historic task to further the integration of the continent by peaceful means, extending a zone of stability and prosperity to new members." www.europa.com/ec/enlarge European Union Enlargement

The Nature, Incidence And Significant Of New Religious Movements In The West

1829 words - 7 pages The Nature, incidence and significance of new religious movements in the West. Introduction The emergence and rapid growth of many new religious movements since WWII has caught the attention of the public, media and academia alike and has been the source of interest, fear and controversy. Sects and cults have many definitions depending on the user's frame of reference. Beckford describes cults as "...relatively small, new, and unconventional

Why Was The War Of 1812 Favored By The South And West And Opposed By New England? Includes A Bibliogrophy

858 words - 3 pages Why was the war of 1812 favored by the south and west and opposed by New England?The War of 1812 is one of the most complex wars of the United States. The war lasted for over two years, and while it ended as it had started, in stalemate, it was in fact a war that once and for all confirmed American Independence. The United States declared War on Great Britain on June 12, 1812. The war was declared as a result of long simmering disputes with