The Effectiveness Of Private School Vouchers

1358 words - 5 pages

Today, a solid education is what any parent should desire for their child. Without that education there is really no successful future ahead of them. Many parents and teachers have been very supportive of the Common Core Standards, but many are against it and feel that it puts an unnecessary strain on students, parents, and teachers. Several states now offer vouchers that give students the opportunity to attend private schools if the student or parents feel that their education goals are not being met through the public school system. But how beneficial are these vouchers to everyone, including taxpayers? It seems that more research needs to be done to see what the real cost is, if it truly allows children from low income families to attend without a financial burden, and to see if the students transferring from public schools to private schools are becoming more successful in achieving their educational goals.

In 2006 President Bush as well as other GOP members introduced a plan that would allow students attending public schools that were not receiving a quality education the chance to attend private schools as well as religious schools (Bush). Although this may seem like a wonderful opportunity and many may have jumped on board immediately if given the chance, there is one thing in particular that does not sound appropriate with this bill. If this bill allows students to attend religious schools, it seems that it could be an issue of separation of church and state. However, these vouchers are publicly funded which means that taxpayers really have no say in where their tax dollars will be going (10 Reasons Why). In other words, no matter what your religious belief is or even if you have no belief, you have no other choice but to help fund this program.

Another area to look at is to see if the vouchers are truly beneficial for low income families. In Cleveland, Ohio reports showed that many families who received a voucher did not follow through with private schooling due to the additional cost that the voucher would not cover (10 Reasons Why). It seems that there might be little information being passed on to voucher recipients. Are they not being informed that there may be additional costs that are not covered by the voucher, and are the family’s financial records not being reviewed by the government beforehand so that they are not being led on with high hopes of their child being able to attend that school. There is also the possibility that many private schools will not even participate in the voucher program due to some of their limitations on the number of students that they can accept (Robelen). So it seems very important to make families aware of the schools that will be participating so they are not going through the process just to be told that there is no school in their area that is participating in the program.

In New Orleans, Louisiana in 2008 there were many mixed emotions regarding vouchers being issued. Many people were...

Find Another Essay On The Effectiveness of Private School Vouchers

School Vouchers are NOT the Solution

1178 words - 5 pages sectarian missions. (School Vouchers: The Wrong Choice, 2001). For example, Federal appeals courts have prohibited the government from lending instructional materials to parochial schools. The United States Department of Education conducted a survey that essentially asked private schools if they would be willing to meet accountability standards under a voucher system. A controversy stemming from the survey is the question of whether or

Pros and Cons of Inner City School Vouchers

1812 words - 7 pages interested in a private or parochial school education. In Virginia there is the Children First Virginia Scholarship Fund (Foster). This option receives donations and grants from outside organizations and redistributes the money in the form of vouchers that are meant to allow for low income families to send their kids to private schools, or to go to a better public school in the immediate area (Foster). Privately funded voucher organizations

Determining The Effectiveness of an After-School Program

1944 words - 8 pages While no one can deny the benefits of after-school programs, their effectiveness at furthering the education in our schools can be called into question. While what can be considered effective in after-school programs can be contingent upon the basic goals and objectives of the individual program, if the after-school program is not reaching the goals of the program it cannot be considered an effective program despite the good it may be providing

The Effectiveness of Willy Russell's Presentation of the School Trip in Our Day Out

2966 words - 12 pages The Effectiveness of Willy Russell's Presentation of the School Trip in Our Day Out 'Our day out' was written as a television play in 1977 but taken directly from Willy Russell's personal experience of teaching in a Liverpool comprehensive school in 1974. Not only does Willy Russell's experience stem from his time in teaching but also from being a pupil at two Liverpool comprehensive schools, leaving at 15 with no

The Effectiveness of Corporal Punishment on Correcting Behavior of Middle School Children

897 words - 4 pages Corporal Punishment and its Effectiveness on Correcting a Child’s Behavior in the Middle School Setting: Sixth Grade through Eighth Grade A Research Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of Requirements for the EDU 501 Research Method Freed-Hardeman University March 24, 2014 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction to the Study…………………………………………………3 Statement of the Problem……………………………………………………..3 Description of Corporal

The Definition of Private

534 words - 2 pages The Definition of Private Anyone who has ever received one of those pesky telemarketer phone calls during dinner most likely understands the idea of a private phone number. No one likes to have their phone line invaded by paid phone operators who just want your money. Working long and hard on a group presentation regarding technology threatening/improving privacy, one can realize that the word private has several different connotations and

The Effectiveness of Sanctions

2099 words - 8 pages most such actors generally develop a range of circumvention strategies that can minimize or outweigh the intended effects of sanctions. Such processes explain, for instance, the increased use of available resources for immediate private ends”. (Chesterman, 2003, pg.9) The United Nations has put itself in a position where most countries consider them a “paper tiger”, unable to resolve any issues and their resolution remains completely

Evaluating Effectiveness of NYU Polytechnic School of Engineering

1934 words - 8 pages 1. You are a consultant to NYU Polytechnic. The President insists that effectiveness must be evaluated by an increase in student population, particularly at the undergraduate level. The Director of the Management Department insists that the main goal is to update the curriculum. The Dean of Academic Affairs states that controlling costs should be the key focus. What would you suggest that the school do to ensure that effectiveness is

The Benefits of Private Enterprise

1452 words - 6 pages Private enterprise is the ironclad foundation of the United States of America. Whenever this right is jeopardized, the stability of the country follows in a symmetric trend. However, the value of this system has not always been clear. Throughout time no country has embraced this system quite like the United States. Private enterprise entails the right to market and sell a product or service, as well as the right of purchase. Indeed the

The Effectiveness of HomeSchooling Instruction

2327 words - 9 pages considering laws relating to homeschoolers, the process, and access to public education. In August the California Court of Appeal for the Second Appellate District ruled unanimously that “California statutes permit home schooling as a species of private school education.” (Home School Legal Defense Association, 2009) The HSLDA website features the ability to track pending local and federal legislation associated with homeschooling. Arguments are made

The Right of Private Defence

2811 words - 11 pages The right of defence of one's own body or property is an unavoidable right. prior to the times when men began to live as members of organized communities, individuals were completely left to themselves to take whatever action for their protection .Even in ancient times the right of private defence had significance. Ancient law givers like Manu gave the authority of using arms in self defence in times of fear of danger. There were no limitations

Similar Essays

Private School Vouchers Essay

2552 words - 10 pages Proposals to use private school vouchers, a marketplace strategy, as a mechanism by which to improve the general quality of public education have produced a lively debate. Frequently, that debate has degenerated into a disagreement about whether public schools are as good as private schools or whether a given private school is better than a certain neighborhood public school. Other issues raised in these discussions include the appropriate use

The Problem Of Vouchers And School Choice

1138 words - 5 pages have no schools of their own and allow all their students to pick from surrounding public and private schools, applying their tax dollars to those entities. They talk about the successes of magnet schools and charter schools and link the school choice concept to our basic rights under the Constitution.   What kind of American would argue with that? What kind of capitalist would disagree with the beneficial effect on performance brought about

School Vouchers Are The Solution Essay

1673 words - 7 pages of funding that is devoted to education and directs it to consumers rather than to school districts. This gives families the freedom to choose any school and thus send their children to institutions they feel are best suited to their children’s needs. There are government funded vouchers, as well as that made available by private institutions. I feel that one good way would be to do it through gigantic corporations, who have the capital and may

Trend Of Public School Vouchers Over Time

2824 words - 12 pages students to attend parochial and private schools with a voucher up to $2,250 (PFAW). In the 1996-97 school year, 1,994 vouchers were given. The current 2001-2002 school year has 4,266 vouchers. Vouchers are assigned by a random lottery.The Florida voucher program is a statewide program based on school ratings. If a school receives two failing grades in a four-year period, vouchers are offered to the students of the failing school. Private schools are