"The Third Man" Suggests That Sometimes It Is Necessary To Put Loyalty Aside And Betray A Friend.

1128 words - 5 pages

Carol Reed's direction of "The Third Man", coupled with Graham Greene's screenplay, continually thrust forward the notion that the betrayal of a friend is forgivable in the light of a greater good. However, what one considers the correct, moral course of action is totally dependant upon their preference of what is considered to be the pinnacle form of 'morality', that being the highest stranded of integrity a human can display. 'The Third Man' arguably considers the betrayal of a friend acceptable in light of the common good, and throughout the movie it is seen that the arguments for maintaining loyalty and friendship are slowly overridden by the notion of duty one feels in their pursuit of the 'right' course of action to take. Holly and Harry both display signs of betrayal to each over the course of the film; whether it is due to the sacrifice they feel they are required to make in order to achieve a higher stance of moral achievement, or rather in the latter's case, a lack of ethical consideration towards humanity in general - though it can clearly be seen in each case that loyalty can just as easily be discarded in the face of a more impertinent purpose.The necessity of betrayal is most easily shown through Holly Martins, the protagonist of the story whose gullible, unquestioning and persistent nature all result in an easily swayed man who ultimately decides to be a "dumb, decoy duck" in order to capture Lime and thus cease the heavy weight on his own conscience. Holly, by becoming involved in matters of no concern to him, is emotionally experienced and too superficial to properly deal with the type of deep thought and contemplation involved in the decision between betrayal and the maintenance of the common good. It is not that Holly makes the wrong decision by betraying his friend, rather, it is the fact that his opinions are easily swayed with proof of the evidence, both through his meeting with Lime who questions him as to whether he would "Calculate how many dots (humans) you could afford to spare"; and through the presentation of Lime's young victims. It cannot be denied that Harry's staunch defense of Lime's innocence quickly crumbles underneath the production of hard fact, and this reinforces the moral integrity of Holly; who was once so obedient to staying blind to the truth. Such evidence gives the audience more than enough material against Harry in order for them to side with Holly, and hence prove to them the boundaries of how much loyalty one can main, and where the frontiers between betrayal and friendship can finally be breached.Easily the most charming, cultured and likeable character in the movie, Lime also provides a sharp juxtaposition to Holly's reasons for betrayal. There are several instances where Lime is seen on the verge of betrayal to his good friend, however chances for this are often dissipated as soon as they appear such as Anna's presence in the café scene where Lime yells at her to "get out of the way", all...

Find Another Essay On "The Third Man" suggests that sometimes it is necessary to put loyalty aside and betray a friend.

It is sometimes claimed that friends have now become more important than families or kin. Discuss some of the differences between family and friends

1411 words - 6 pages , often hidden, ways by what happens in the wider world". This suggests that as individuals we need the influence of the outside world to assist in our decision-making processes. However, both family and friendship relationships offer a range of external (social) and internal (private) life networks from which the individual or group can access personal and social knowledge, resources and support.The difference in the level, mannerism and depth of

Why is perfect competition sometimes regarded as an ideal market structure and why does Samuelson write that it doesn't faithfully represent the facts about modern industry?

545 words - 2 pages or fall. As should be, there is a freedom of entry and exit of firms. Both the consumers and producers have a perfect knowledge of market conditions. The demand curve is equal to the marginal revenue curve meaning that the firm sells whatever it produces and there is no inventory tax. Having MR=MC, the firm makes as much profit as possible.Perfect competition is the most stable market form, and hence the most desirable. It leads to the best

Q1) “In The Extracts, Seneca Maintains That Practising Philosophy is Necessary for a Person to Live a Good Life. Do You Agree and Why?”

1556 words - 7 pages a way of life, with virtue, it brings noble meaning and hence, fulfilment to our existence. As Seneca (Nat. quest. ex 4-5) proclaims, “If I had not been admitted to these [philosophical] studies, it would not have been worthwhile being born … What a pitiful thing is man unless he rises above human concerns!” Sellars (2006, p. 36) confirms that philosophy was established as the education on the method for the soul to undergo metamorphosis, so

Homeland Security: The Patriot Act, is it a necessary evil?

1298 words - 6 pages ? When is the line drawn on how much power the government can have? Is the Patriot Act effective enough that it is necessary? Should we as Americans willing to trade freedom for safety? Can the Patriot Act effectively stop or hinder terrorist attacks; has its stopped enough attacks to be validated? Another question is does America want a government that has that much power, how much are we as Americans willing to sacrifice, and how much more liberty’s

Democracy: The Struggle That Is and How to Fix It

1251 words - 6 pages reliant on people agreeing to compromise, it is clear to see that this system will not be efficient. But, democracy offers its citizens incentives and rewards that more top-heavy styles of government cannot. Democracy is a struggle, but it is the job of the people to cook up the effort to give the system the fair chance of survival that it needs. This course started out by looking at the most prolific liberal thinkers in history, the first amongst

Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God

1058 words - 4 pages Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God Rational: To be rational is to think logically and within reason. To base your thoughts on evidence, and then use that evidence to come to a "rational" conclusion. Motivation: To be motivated to do or think something, normally the motivation will be because it will benefit you in the long run. Many philosophers use theses types of words when

Put the homeless to work, but is is that easy? Contains personal opinions

1195 words - 5 pages This is a simple thing to say but is it really this easy to put homeless people to work? There are a lot of questions that we need to answer regarding this issue. Will the homeless really volunteer and help clean up the city of San Diego? Will this be a short term plan or is there a chance that we can get them to work permanently? These are just some of the many questions that arises when we talk about the homeless people. I agree with the idea

Is it Necessary to Imitate others?

955 words - 4 pages actually a key component to being successful in any line of work. How would athletes be great at a sport they play without some kind of role model? How would actors be able to perform at an outstanding level on the big screen without some style, or memorization techniques that have been passed down to them from others? After doing research, and looking at real life examples, it has become crystal clear to me on why imitating is necessary in

Is it really necessary to use gender-neutral language? A short essay discussing the importance of non-sexist language

550 words - 2 pages Is it really necessary to use gender-neutral language?It is very important to use non-sexist language, even if a person does not have any discriminative intentions at all. Everyone, consciously or not, tends to assign masculine gender to terms, such as "man", even when this word is used for "human beings". "Man", amongst other expressions or grammatical constructions, should be avoided.Every language reflects the prejudices of the society in

Is it Really Necessary to have a Certificate in Order to be a Paralegal?

652 words - 3 pages There has been a issue for years when one hears three words as simple as regulating Paralegal profession .The Supreme Court has been trying to enforce paralegals to be certified in order to call them self paralegals, for years. The real question still at hand is who will benefit from it and who will not. Is it really necessary to have a Certificate in order to be a paralegal if one has performed the job for years without it. What are the

This is a creative writing piece about my friend almost drowning. It has four parts to it, each tells the same story from a different perspective

1449 words - 6 pages ." He responded. Whenever they get into a fight, he reminds her of the day. She has no recollection of the pool, how cold the water was, or how traumatic the day. To her it is a memory invented by those who experienced it. Her mother tells her how scared she was, her brother reminds her that her life was at stake, and her dad remains silent. She doesn't know that the glass shattered, or that the ambulance came, all she knows is that she is

Similar Essays

Affecting Change The Paper Talkes About The Necessary Changes That A Company Sometimes Needs To Go Through In Order To Grow

1679 words - 7 pages reason being that, as a student and later a business person, there are places to go, grades to make, goals to meet. In an environment like this one, a set guideline, or procedure has to be implemented in order to increase the chance for success, whether it's a good grade, a deadline, a quota, or personal goal. A company is no different than an individual when it comes to pursuing an end goal, or an end result. Therefore, the implementations of

Teachers Should Put Aside Socio Economic Status Stereotypes And Expect The Best To Get The Best

2428 words - 10 pages they know that on a daily basis! Start Here Findings and Feelings It wasn’t until after I read, “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack” by Peggy McIntosh (1990) that I realized I am at an advantage for being white. I have never been one to judge that of another color. My best friend is African-American and has been for approximately 10 years now. When I began reading the white privilege checklist McIntosh (1990) provided, it was a

What Is The Real Purpose Of Education? Are We In It Simply For The Purpose Of Learning? Essay Suggests That There Is More To An Education Than Books

782 words - 3 pages "School Teaches Us More Than Just Words"As a child, I remember my mother telling me to make sure I succeed in school so that when I grow up I can be somebody. I told her I wanted to be a doctor and that I would do my best and make her proud. In reality, what was the purpose of this education that I would receive in my future years? Education is there to make us all well-rounded and not just educated individuals. The whole purpose of education is

To What Extent Is The Third Man A "Parable For The Damned"?

1331 words - 5 pages To What Extent Is The Third ManA "Parable For The Damned"?The Third Man by Graham Greene is a mystery novella. It is the story of Rollo Martins who is damned to betray his friend; Harry Lime, in order to find justice. The novella takes place in Vienna during the four-power occupation.Graham Greene is an English writer, playwright and literary critic. He was one of the select few to have been awarded the Order of Merit and to have been created a