To What Extent Can “All My Sons” Be Seen As A Criticism Of “The American Dream” And The American Way Of Life?

2092 words - 9 pages

The American Dream was born out of the deprivation of the war and the great depression America went through; measured by affluence, a rise in the accepted standard of living, it was the total opposite to war times.“ Everyman a king. All things even better” In Miller’s play the Keller family are seen to be living the “American Dream”, yet their ways and means of obtaining this are greatly criticised by Miller.

The Keller’s live in an outer-city suburb in a house that “would have cost perhaps fifteen thousand in the early twenties”. Another indication of this is when Joe throws out the vegetables mistaking them for garbage, as this level of waste would not even be consider during the war and perhaps for some time after, but Joe is indifferent, shown when he says “I can afford another bag of potatoes”. The Keller’s also have a maid, another sign of wealth. Also when Chris tells Joe of his marriage plans he decides to take him out for dinner, where there will be ”big time tonight” with “steak” and “champagne” which would have still been not easily affordable luxuries. This can suggest that by the way Joe is splashing his money about that he is not ashamed of his wealth and sees no wrong in what he has done as he has worked hard to earn it for himself ans his family.

Joe Keller represents everyman, he is a “man among men” with strong family values (“A father is a father”). He runs a successful business that engineered aeroplane parts throughout the war, and knowingly sent out parts with defects so not to lose profit, his denial of these actions led to Steve Deever, Ann and George’s father being imprisoned. Joe feels he did nothing wrong and shows very little guilt throughout the play, which he covers up by putting on a façade and is perhaps why he can spend his money so unashamedly. He shows recognition of his actions when he says to Chris “I’m a business man… a hundred and twenty cylinder heads cracked, you’re out of business… you lay forty years into a business and they knock you out in five minutes…when would I have had another chance to make something for you?” and he justifies his actions as he wanted to create a future for Chris ( “I want you to use what a made for you… without shame”) and it is possible for him to do this as Chris is innocent of Joe’s guilt.

Larry and Chris especially are the soldiers who fought in the war for America’s stability and their opinion of “the American Dream” differs vastly from that of Joe. Chris says “I felt wrong to be alive, to open the bank book, to drive the new car, to see the new refrigerator.. What you have is really loot, and there’s blood on “ and this can suggest that he doesn’t understand how people can act as if a war hadn’t occurred and so many hadn’t died, as if it was “a bus accident” and I think he may feel this way as he was out there and saw the monstrosities of war, yet this was never really felt back at home. He picks up on the notion that war-profiteering was occurring when he says that...

Find Another Essay On To what Extent Can “All My Sons” be Seen as a Criticism of “the American Dream” and the American Way of Life?

All My Sons , Miller's Chief Criticism Of American Society

684 words - 3 pages A shot was heard throughout the Keller home as Joe ended his guilty, worthless life. Miller criticizes that American society has become corrupt- a place of selfishness, where people care too much about themselves, and that which benefits them, and will go to any lengths to achieve that goal; even if the repercussions of their actions will bring harm to other people. He stresses that money seems to be the key factor that drives society to

To what extent can the 1936 popular front government be seen as a missed opportunity for social transformation

2255 words - 9 pages Daladier's 'Cartel des gauches'. This was perceived by the left wing, particularly the socialists, to be an attempt at a coup d'état, and three days later they staged a counterdemonstration, marking the first tentative union the Socialists and the Communists. The extreme right were numerically weak but seen against the background of fascist activity in other countries, it was understandable that they should be seen to represent a more serious

To what extent can Hardy's Tess be seen as a femme fatale?

979 words - 4 pages Tess's sexual agency, - to what extent can Tess be seen as a femme fatale figure?Tess had heard those notes in the attic above her head. Dim, flattened, constrained by their confinement, they had never appealed to her as now, when they wandered in the still air with a stark quality like that of nudity. To speak absolutely, both instrument and execution were poor; but the relative is all, and as she listened Tess, like a fascinated bird, could

Gatsby's dream was what destroyed him- an essay about The Great Gatsby by Scott Fitzgerald, and the way dreams can destroy the actual life

987 words - 4 pages , this could be viewed also as a criticism to the American society giving sometimes-excessive hopes to everybody. In spite of all that Gatsby manages to succeed. He manages to make his own way, to find his own place. Making profit of the situation in the beginning of the thirties and its own inventiveness he manages to earn enough money to buy a rather extravagant house in the most expensive part of New York and "throws" huge parties regularly

The American Dream as it used to be and what it as evovled into: How has the American Dream effected the way hurricane Katrina was handled?

2502 words - 10 pages tendency of change in work ethic has not weakened the desire for the sweet American Dream. It has just changed the way of obtaining it. Many Americans no longer entertain a vision for the future, that includes working hard and putting endless time in to it, a vision that would be the ultimate success for Benjamin Franklin and company. Instead many Americans see work as an evil, which must be endured, until striking it rich in some other way. This

To what extent do Arthur Miller’s works focus on the ideal family model and the concept of the American Dream?

1143 words - 5 pages character suggests, one must be ruthless in order to do this. Here, Miller is stating that the ideal 'rags to riches' element of the American Dream has huge flaws and can effect individuals to the point of disregarding other's feelings in order to achieve it. Biff's view of the American Dream is more of what Miller intends his audience to consider. At first, he aims to follow his father's example towards a capitalist, money fuelled future but as the

A discussion of the american dream as represented in "American Beauty" and "The Great Gatsby"

1491 words - 6 pages uses the unconventional object of the plastic bag to symbolize beauty.Illusion versus reality is explored in Lester's lust for Angela. She is the external catalyst that prompts Lester to step out of his catatonic state, and chase happiness. However she is the conventional beauty, and not what Lester is actually seeking. However, due to the context where external beauty is seen as beauty, Lester lusts for her, and youth. The American dream evolves

To What Extent Can the Problems of Urbanization Be Met by a Policy of Sustainable Development

1577 words - 6 pages first thought to enter the mind is energy saving. The phenomenon of wasting water and electrical energy can be seen everywhere in our lives and there are many energy saving tips which are easy to do. According to Energy Saving Trust (n.d.), it is a good idea to “try to be aware of unnecessary lights left on, and appliances left plugged-in or on standby. Nearly all electrical and electronic appliances can safely be turned off at the plug without

To What Extent Can the Problems of Urbanization be Met by a Policy of Sustainable Development

1815 words - 7 pages , sustainable development can partly solve the urbanization problems, for it can reduce the impact of the problems such as traffic jam, housing shortage and severe pollution, but it is difficult to completely solve these problems in a short time. Traffic jam Traffic jam is one of the most serious problems of urbanization, almost all the modern cities are facing different levels of traffic jam problems. In general, people can ease the traffic jam and

Great Gatsby: Fitzgeralds Criticism Of The American Dream

476 words - 2 pages Great Gatsby: Fitzgerald's Criticism of The American Dream The American Dream, as it arose in the Colonial period and developed in the nineteenth century, was based on the assumption that each person, no matter what his origins, could succeed in life on the sole basis of his or her own skill and effort. The dream was embodied in the ideal of the self-made man, just as it was embodied in Fitzgerald's own family by his grandfather, P. F

A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry: A Criticism of the American Dream Analytical Paper

1428 words - 6 pages of their dreams were part of their daily life and difficult to overcome in the. What adds to the hardships of black American families is a generation gap that seems to widen due to the diverging perceptions of the American Dream. Thereby, the aspirations for financial success, that were especially present among younger generations, display a far-off shot from the original paradigm of the American Dream, which used to be the pursuit of happiness

Similar Essays

To What Extent Can Violence Be Seen As A Catalyst To The Advancement Of African American Civil Rights In The Period 1865 1965

2771 words - 12 pages . This is supported by Malcolm X, who said, “When people are sad, they don’t do anything, they just cry over their condition, but when they get angry they bring about a change . The American Civil War is testament to how violence can be a key factor in influencing Civil Rights. According to Fitzgerald (2005), after Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation of 1863, the abolition of Slavery became one of the main issues of the war and with the

To What Extent Can Violence Be Seen As A Catalyst To The Advancement Of African American Civil Rights In The Period 1865 1965

1253 words - 6 pages how events such as the freedom rides and the Children’s Crusades precipitated violence and created change also support the idea that Violence was a catalyst. Most of all the admissions of James Farmer and Martin Luther King that the use of non-violent protest was aimed to precipitate violence show that even the leaders of the time understood that violence catalyzed the civil rights struggle. Works Cited 1. Mumford, K. (7/2/2013). A minute

The American Dream: A Conflict Essay Of "Death Of A Salesman" And "All My Sons"

1269 words - 5 pages "Death of a Salesman" and "All My Sons" are centered around one man trying to attain the American dream. Few will deny that Americans are keenly focused on the quest for money. The American Dream is the belief that through hard work, courage, and willpower one could attain a better life for oneself and family, more often than not through financial wealth. The difficult part is, once attained, the methods and knowledge need to be passed from one

To What Extent Can 'the Violets' Be Seen As A Representative Of The Poetic Qualities And Concerns Of Harwood's Work?

1481 words - 6 pages To what extent can 'The Violets' be seen as a representative of the poetic qualities and concerns of Harwood's work? Base your discussion on a detailed analysis of this poem and one of the other set poems.Through the collection of Gwen Harwood's works there are evident traits, qualities, concerns and thematic ideas that are brought up distinctively in all of her works. With the quality of her language and techniques which are wildly eloquent and