Torture Is Morally Justifiable In Some Extreme Cases (Write A Letter To The Editor In Respose To Mirko Bagaric's Article).

1020 words - 4 pages

Whose distorted moral judgments?Torture, a controversial word, is defined by Paris Aristotle, the director of the Victorian Foundation for survivors of Torture as being " not just the physical applications of pain, but it requires the complete subjugation of the person at emotional, psychological and spiritual levels." It seems to be a complex definition, however torture is in fact much worse. As a survivor of torture I felt disgusted upon reading Mirko Bagaric's article supporting torture as an "excellent information gathering device" to "save the lives of thousands of innocent people". Torture is undoubtedly immoral, ineffective as well as rendering permanent scars inside the victim's head.A few years after I was released from my ordeal my movements were still restricted and I could hardly speak. I knew I had been tortured for something I had taken no part in. I knew that I was free but I also knew that I wanted to stay far away from the street and people and be seen as little as possible. I had become branded by something terrible and remained inside the house, hardly making a sound, always looking fearfully out the window worrying over the slightest knock on the door.I can still feel all the terror and anguish that I had years ago as I write this today. My horror of being tortured was magnified by the realisation that it was being done to me by another human being. It is a perversion and destruction of the very idea of human morality. I have accepted that these things happen in my country, but not here in Australia.Australia does not endorse the death penalty, even for the most heinous crimes, and even where the convict has been given a fair trial and exhausted a lengthy appeals process because Australia recognises that mistakes are made. But here is Bagaric stating that it should be permissible to kill an innocent person who "almost certainly" has information that the authority would like. "In those circumstances you would start with a minimum degree of harm; if that didn't work, you would escalate it, and if that unfortunately resulted in an innocent person being killed, in those circumstances that would be justified. I think as a society we would accept that one person being killed to save thousands is legitimate" and that "even if the individual tortured were killed and later proven innocent, or even if the threat of harm turned out to be false, torture still would have been justified because we must decide on the best evidence at the time".It seems that Bagaric conveniently left out the fact that, if that 'innocent' person were killed and the threat of harm was real, it would not save the lives of thousands of people at all. In those circumstances it would be the thousands of people who will in fact die, in addition to that poor victim of torture.In addition to that, who comprises the "we" that makes the decision? Would it be the same governments, military and intelligence chiefs who insisted that Iraq had to be invaded because "on the...

Find Another Essay On Torture is Morally Justifiable in Some Extreme Cases (write a letter to the editor in respose to Mirko Bagaric's article).

Going to Extreme Lengths in "The Crucible"

616 words - 2 pages Have you ever been overwhelmingly passionate about something that you would do anything it took to accomplish it? Sometimes people go to extreme lengths to get what they want. The Crucible is a play that shows us that trait. In The Crucible by Arthur Miller, Abigail Williams does just that. Abigail William's desire for John Proctor creates her dishonest and manipulative actions that affect the whole village. Abigail loves John Proctor even

This is a letter to the editor of a newspaper. It argues about ex-offenders getting a second chance at work. ;-) Enjoy!

721 words - 3 pages Letter to the EditorI'm writing a letter in reference and response to the February seventeenth editorial "Ex-offenders deserve second chance" by Tom Andrzejewski that appeared in the Plain Dealer. I think that Tom is only chipping the surface on that subject. The job outlook for ex-offenders is slim and hungry. The possibilities for ex-offenders range of only a few jobs and positions; two being a factory position as a laborer or in some type of

This essay is about how a divorce is, in some cases, better than the couple staying together

593 words - 2 pages though they don't want anything to do with one another, all because they did not look at the consequences of their actions. Eventually they will wear at each other's nerves until one of them snaps and a divorce happens anyway. In extreme cases one might hurt the other out of pure frustration. Not getting a well-needed divorce can prohibit them from finding someone they like. By entering the dating world too late, a person might not have the time

The War in Iraq is Not Justifiable

4198 words - 17 pages The War in Iraq is Not Justifiable Thousands of young men and women are sent overseas to be killed or injured only to return crippled for life or in a coffin. I commend all in the military for their service and I would never disrespect any soldier. In fact, my best friend?s brother entered the United States Navy out of high school and has served three years so far; he is in active duty serving on an aircraft carrier. I have the same


928 words - 4 pages children posses the capacity to acquire native-like proficiency in their language at all linguistic levels. After that, the author focuses on the adult's acquisition. The article illustrates the problem clearly. As a result, we can say that the topic or problem investigated in the article clearly identified.The rational for the study is in some way clearly described. For example, in the main topic adult's acquisition in phonology, as the author

A response to Aristotle's Politics, stating that all mankind is in the pursuit of some good

906 words - 4 pages Mankind's underlying lifestyle"All associations are instituted for the purpose of attaining some good" (375). In agreement with Aristotle, I believe everything as we know it, is formed, is said, and is carried out, with some extent of good in mind. Another way of putting this would be that the ultimate end goal of human existence is happiness. By saying this, he has come to say that no body goes into any action that may be a malicious event just

Given it's controverial nature, should The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn continue to be taught in schools? Write a persuasive letter to the school board

1225 words - 5 pages Dear School Board,The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a controversial novel which many schools seek to ban, while others want it to be taught. I, Siddharth Vyas, as a high school student of an international school, write this letter to you as a means of revealing the reality of this novel. As author of the book, Mark Twain underlies such themes as racism, slavery, and societal conflicts portrayed by the thoughts of a social outcast, namely

A Play I Wrote for my "Modern Femininity" Class. Some people might find it offensive. It was in response to the assignment "Write a Creative Response to Changing Role of Males in Modern Parenting"

5176 words - 21 pages see if I have any Hippo music. Ah here is one for you, a little Mitch Miller. He has quite the rebellious streak in him. You can tell, he has one of those goat beards.Ronald: Perhaps I should get Hambone to go fetch some reefer cigarettes, the kind the hippos like to smoke?Margaret: Where would you even go to buy those?Ronald: Maybe the pharmacy at Woolworths.Margaret: Yes, I would imagine they would have those. They did have that ointment I was

Is Euthanasia Morally and Philosophically Justifiable?

911 words - 4 pages When considering whether the piece of legislation titled “The Death with Dignity Act” is morally and philosophically justifiable, the moral and philosophic viability of what is referred to as active voluntary euthanasia must first be evaluated. Because active voluntary euthanasia seeks to reduce the amount of suffering of the patients as well as offer individuals greater control over their life it can be justified, and the “Death with Dignity

Do you think it is morally acceptable for an employer to make rules against dating in the workplace?

1238 words - 5 pages possibly asking her out it was explained to me that that type of relationship was inappropriate. In fact it was most frowned upon when a dating relationship takes place between a commissioned officer and an enlisted member. The main reason for this type of relationship is because it can cause a conflict of interest. A person that holds a position of authority as a commissioned officer has a relationship with an enlisted person it can cause

"Advice To youth" by Mark Twain The teacher asked us to read this short story and them write a summery of it and relate to the world or our lives in some way

1018 words - 4 pages "Advice To youth" by Mark Twain is basically a short little composition that he was asked to write to the youth's of America. Basically it was just meant to be something to be educational and useful in life. I think that what he said back then is just as true today as it was back then when he wrote it.He starts off by saying that you should always listen to what your parents say even if you don't agree because if you try to rebel against them

Similar Essays

Letter To The Editor Essay

894 words - 4 pages To the Editor, It is quite noticeable that obesity rates in the United States are continually rising. When a person is obese, they have an increase risk to diseases such as type-2 diabetes, heart disease, various cancers, etc. (Haslam & James 2005). There are countless studies conducted to see the possible effects obesity can cause to an individual. One study concluded, if two obese individuals have a child, that child has a high percentage of

Multi Culture Complications; Please Write A 2 3 Page Paper Identifying Some Of These "Cultural Mistakes" From The First Article Listed Below ("The Pitfalls Of Cross Cultural Business").

983 words - 4 pages domestic audience. When a product is then marketed at an international audience the same domestic advertising campaign abroad will in most cases be ineffective. (Payne, Neil) The type of business propositioned in new countries and cultures is also of importance. If you were trying to expand your Pork chop franchise in India, you would still be offending about 12% of the community. McDonalds went through many "baby-steps" and protests

"Native Son" Letter To The Editor

801 words - 3 pages To Whom It May Concern:I am writing this letter in response to your dyslogical, racist, and slanderous article “Negro Rapist Faints at Inquest” in your newspaper The Tribune. I believe that your portrayal of Bigger Thomas is unfair and was created with the sole interest of inciting panic, hysteria, and outrage in the white community. I also believe that your unsatisfactory work is leading to the consequences of rioting in the streets and angry

Stolen Generation; Letter To The Editor

797 words - 3 pages RE: Letter to the editorIn reply to your letter, I would like to inform you, that the policy regarding the removal of Aboriginal children was not as you stated. As soon as a child was born, they were considered a ward of the state because of their Aboriginality.The policy of Assimilation was established in 1911 for the removal of children from their community to extinguish their culture. This is also known as Genocide, but was not seen that way