Use Of Animal In Scientific Research

1584 words - 6 pages

“Maybe not wrong for everyone---it was clearly a complicated and individual choice---but wrong for me” (McCarthy 638). The use of animals in scientific research provokes ethical issues and casts doubt on the reliability of using animals in testing. Alternatives to animal testing are accessible and should be used instead of living animals.
The personal choices dealing with animal testing proposes ethical issues that make people use their intuition. The preservation of life is choice. Poste says, “A hallmark of humanity is our ability to care about other species” (Poste). Poste recognizes a genuine principle that is shown throughout history. There have been animals that have almost gone extinct. Something inside of humans recognized this and observed preservation as a necessity. The care inside human’s hearts is what prevented the nearly-extinct animals to continue living. The same care should carry over again for defenseless creatures that are being continuously researched on. McCarthy states, “Nobody seemed happy” (McCarthy 636). McCarthy also identifies a problem when in her essay; she discloses information of the first grout to finish their lab on animal research, namely dogs. The disdain that McCarthy saw in her fellow colleagues leads the reader to see that something inside them felt bad. Furthermore, the human desire is to protect lives, not execute them. That feeling of hurt or the need to take care of something reiterates the preservation of life that is inside everyone. Evidenced by the researchers’ compassion, humans’ feelings towards animals are very personal. In the article, “An Ethical Argument Against Vivisection”, “Animals are seen simply as resources – as little more than products to make our lives more convenient and comfortable” (“An Ethical Argument Against Vivisection”). This article focuses on how humans view animals. Merely as tools to be used whenever is convenient, animals are considered to be the inferior species. Since animals have no say, humans are their only voice. Humans are to stand up for animals. Poste reiterates, “My advice is that people carefully consider not just whether or not a group shares their beliefs, but whether or not they behave in an ethical manner” (Poste). Humans are to look deep into their hearts and see if their actions reflect how they feel and if they can live with those decisions. Creating a conflict in the heart, animal testing can divide, confuse, and potentially hurt the soul, and most people do not look at that entire picture of animal testing. They only think about the products gained. Humans' feelings are crucial because they can determine the life of an animal. Because humans have total control, the morality of animal testing is determined on individual choices. McCarthy acknowledges that, “The knowledge I had gained wasn't worth the life of a dog to me” (McCarthy 638). Deciding whether or not animal testing is harmful can preserve lives. In the case of McCarthy, she regrettably...

Find Another Essay On Use of Animal in Scientific Research

Scientific Research in Psychology Essay

1203 words - 5 pages Research is to find information and solve problem systematic and logically. In psychology, scientific research method is implemented to approach and reveal knowledge in better understanding of our human mind and behaviour. This research is known as basic research. Applied research is to solve and analysis on psychological problem. Psychology research is needed to identify the problem and find solution to solve problem encounter. These two

The Use Of Animal Imagery In Othello

942 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare’s play “Othello” the use of animal imagery was evident throughout the telling of the story. Shakespeare explained several characters actions by comparing them to similarities in animals. The characters in “Othello” were often depicted as having animal-like characteristics. Some characters were even compared to animals by other characters in the play. By defining characters in terms of these characteristics one

The Use of Language in Animal Farm

727 words - 3 pages The Use of Language in Animal Farm Animal Farm by George Orwell is an allegory in which animals are personified to represent the struggles and conflicts of the Russian Revolution. The main point emphasizes in the novel is that language is a powerful tool, which can be used to manipulate and control people in order to bring about change, whether big or small. In the story the pigs govern everything that happens, whether

Ethics of Animal Research

747 words - 3 pages Ethics of Animal Research One of the many issues of today's conversations is still confusing on my understanding it. Is it ethical for people to engage in animal research for human excellence? And if so, just how far can animal research be taken to meet these achievements for human kind? When thinking about this, I would conclude that animals over human beings do not have any rights what so ever, but I would be the biggest hypocrite in

Effects of Antimicrobial Use in Concetrated Animal Feeding Operations

2504 words - 11 pages both the scientific and popular literature is that the majority of antimicrobial use in CAFOs is for purposes of growth promotion and prophylaxis of diseases resultant from high-density food animal production, such as respiratory and enteric conditions, which can cause significant production losses at sub-clinical levels. The annual reports of total tonnage of antimicrobials used in U.S. livestock production are frequently cited as supporting

Use of Propaganda in Animal Farm, by George Orwell

799 words - 4 pages increase to opposite ends of the equality spectrum. At the beginning of the life of Animal Farm, the animals went through the day together, as a single group as seen here with the use of “they”. “Then they filed back to the farm buildings and halted in silence outside the door of the farmhouse.” (Orwell 22) Towards the end of the book, things change. “About this time, too, it was laid down as a rule that when a pig and any other animal met on the

The Use of Animals in Medical Research

993 words - 4 pages addiction, and senility.Animal rights advocates challenge the use of animals in research, arguing that besides being inhumane, it is unnecessary. In addition, they claim that laboratory animals are abused.Critics of animal experimentation question whether animals are really needed for medical research. They point to the many alternative methodologies that have been developed and question whether animal experimentation has provided any benefits that

The Use of Animals in Research

808 words - 3 pages Monkeys would remain the most important symbol for the growing animal rights movement” (Guillermo 12). Biomedical research was the primary use of these monkeys. The book tells of the unsanitary conditions that the monkeys lived in, of the animal cruelty they endured, and the group that fought for their freedom. Through many court battles and several of the monkeys dying, PETA finally saved the remaining monkeys. This was just the start of PETA’s

The use of animals in medical research

665 words - 3 pages such as the Guinea Pig, which contributed to 23 Nobel Prizes for medicines in discovery of Vitamin C, the tuberculosis bacterium and adrenaline as well as many other diseases and infections. There are no specific references in the Bible, which state anything about animal testing. However, Christians are usually in agreement about the use of animals in medical research. One could possibly interpret from the Creation (Gensis:1) `Rule over the fish

Banning Animal Use in Circuses

719 words - 3 pages 71% of the circus animals observed by the study suffered medical problems.("Animal abuse facts and Stats") The use of animals in circuses should be banned because of the credulity towards the animals. Circuses use the method of physical abuse to train the animals. Some circuses also use food and water deprivation to make them do the routines. Wild animals should not be treated poorly. Watching exotic animals do tricks is amusing to people

Use of Animals in Biomedical Research

2235 words - 9 pages still up to us. Works Cited Cohen, Carl. "The Case for the Use of Animals in Biomedical Research." The Norton Reader. Ed Linda H. Peterson, John C. Brereton, Joan E. Hartman. 10th ed. NewYork: Norton, 2000. Frey, R.G. "All Animals Are Not Equal." Animal Rights: Opposing Viewpoints. Ed Andrew Harnkack. Sand Diegy, 1996. Kluger, Jeffrey; Cray, Dan; Kher, Unmesh. "What Mother Nature Teaches Us About Motherhood." Time 155.19 (8 May

Similar Essays

Animal Experimentation In Scientific Research Essay

2561 words - 10 pages For many years, scientists have conducted research to test drugs and other commodities before sending them to human trials and to the market. Often times, these drugs are analyzed by animal testing, which is the “use of [non-human] animals in experiments and development projects usually to determine toxicity, dosing, and efficacy of test drugs before proceeding to human clinical trials” (American Anti-Vivisection Society [AAVS]). These

The Use Of Animal Research Essay

1894 words - 8 pages (Animal Research FAQ's). Animals are useful when they are in controlled experiments where that if something does go wrong scientists are able to understand what had happened. Sometimes during experimentation, the use of its power can be be taken advantage of and when this does happens it is usually in the case of when animals are involved (BostonGlobe) So what animals have that we do not is that they are able to be tested and come up with the most

The Ethics Of Animal Use In Biomedical Research

1986 words - 8 pages surgically manipulated and exploited for money. The use of animals as subjects in biomedical research brings forth two main underlying ethical issues: firstly, the imposition of avoidable suffering on creatures capable of both sensation and consciousness, and secondly the uncertainty pertaining to the notion of animal rights. Although human beings exploit animals for multiple different purposes, the use of animals in scientific research

Animal Use In Psychological Research: Cruel Or Necessary?

637 words - 3 pages are: that the research has an acceptable scientific purpose, and has a reasonable chance of improving the health or welfare of animals or humans. The guideline advises against tests that harm the animal, however if the researchers can prove that the test is important enough they may be able to conduct their studies. Is there middle ground for psychological research in animals? Perhaps there is a more Rogerian solution to the use of animals in