Use And Misuse Of Animals. Essay

1757 words - 7 pages

Before we as a society can decide whether animals have rights or not, we need to keep an open mind. Evolution of life is at least 25 million years old, and from the beginning right to the present day humans have fought for the survival against other species and have evolved to such an extent that they have been taken as the most superior of all living beings. Both Cohen and Williams value human life. They feel if the betterment of humanity is wanted then use of animals has to be accepted. Animals like human beings do suffer but being a lower species they have a tendency to be used by humans. As superiority does not signify cruelty, therfore both the authors value animal life too and are against the misuse of animals. The critics against the use of animals argue about the "rights" of animals. To analyze this, one has to first correctly understand the use of the term "rights" and see how absurd they are on this issue.What does the term "rights" mean? According to Cohen, "a right is a claim, or potential claim, that one party may exercise against another... To comprehend any genuine right fully, one must know who holds the right, against whom it is held, and to what it is a right" (865). Only those who have the capacity to make moral claims against one another can talk about defending rights. Human beings have rights because each one of them has consciously accepted the other's rights and thus will always be self-legislative and morally autonomous. Applying this definition of rights to animals, one can understand why they have been denied rights. As Cohen believes, "animals lack the capacity for free moral judgment" (866). They are incapable of exercising and responding to moral claims and can never recognize the possible conflicts between what is in their own interest and what is just. "Only in a community of beings capable of self restricting moral judgments can the concept of a right be correctly invoked" (Cohen: 866). From this strict and surely logical definition of rights, one can clearly see that a human, a species that has rights, is surely more valuable than animals. And when animals are used in research, for the betterment of human health, one does not violate their rights because they have none to violate.Ingrid Newkirk, the co-director of PETA (People for the Ethnical Treatment of Animals) once made a remark - "When it comes to having a nervous system and the ability to feel pain, hunger and thirst, a rat is a pig is a dog is a boy" (Williams: 63). This again comes down to comparing humans and animals with "equal consideration of interests" (Williams: 64) and rights. Williams has supported Cohen's definition of rights by clearing what kind of rights do we mean exactly? "It's not the right to vote. Not the right to a good education and not the right of a doggy not to be nutted at the vet's" (64). It's the rights or moral claims that humans can make and animals cannot, makes us superior to them. And being superior it is logically...

Find Another Essay On Use and misuse of animals.

Land use and misuse in the uk

860 words - 3 pages Land use and misuse.The United Kingdom has about 24 million hectors of land. million hectors go in to agriculture7 million hectors go in to housinguilding, quarrying and waste disposal are some of the human activities that account for the rest of the land.ach year quarrying produces about 300 million tonnes of gravel, limestone, sand and sandstone for concrete and other building materials.bout 90% of household waste in

The Use and Misuse of Academic Words in Writing by Andrea Marie Cons

1331 words - 5 pages In her article “The Use and Misuse of Academic Words in Writing,” (2012), Andrea Marie Cons compares the writing of students who are developing their English language skills to those who are not native speakers but who have reached a level of proficiency such that they are no longer grouped with second-language learners. While it is true that language is something learned over a lifetime, as new words are invented and new meanings are given to

THE ARGUEMENTS FOR AND AGAINST THE USE OF ANIMALS

2228 words - 9 pages The debate regarding the use of animals in experiments has come under increasing public and political attention throughout the 1980?s and 1990?s. Many objections have been raised against the once accepted scientific procedures by all sectors of society. There are many arguments for and against the use of animals in scientific experimentation most of which revolve around both practical and ethical issues.There are many arguments, which support

The Military Use of Animals

1185 words - 5 pages involving these military animals has not helped the military's cause. These videos show the use of monkeys and goats in medical training which is evidence that the military is violating its own animal welfare regulations (Lawrence 1). These military's response has not helped their cause either, a former military medic responded to these videos saying that these training videos are not enough to replicate actual battle combat, but the use and training

Therapeutic Use of Animals Description

1608 words - 6 pages dedicated knowledge of the profession (Powell, 2012). Potential Target Groups Research demonstrates that the therapeutic use of animals may be beneficial to a wide range of individuals. Research findings support the positive benefits of therapeutic animals working with the geriatric population within nursing homes, long-term care and hospital settings (Banks & Banks, 2002). Also within the hospital setting, therapeutic animals have been used

The Use of Animals in Medical Research

993 words - 4 pages life span of laboratory animals enables researchers to conduct certain studies and experiments that would not be possible on human beings because of the longer life span of humans.Researchers use animals to learn more about common animal and human disorders. Animals contribute to the growing fund of knowledge about genetics, psychology, and neurology. They are providing valuable in their contributions to the fields of mental illness, drug

The use of animals in medical research

665 words - 3 pages Untitled Uses of animals in Medical Research" Animals have a right to a life free from pain and suffering." Discuss with reference to Christian teachings There is much controversy of the use of animals in medical research. There is no doubt that the use of animals has advanced human medical research in many areas such as asthma therapy, blood transfusion, a diphtheria vaccine and polio and whooping cough vaccines. Animals

Use of Animals in Japanese Fables

1572 words - 6 pages to the Japanese life, I discovered that animals play an important role in Japanese culture. And as in most cultures, stories play a big role just as well. So by the simple use of common sense, any person could assume, and be accurate, that there is a wealth of fables in Japanese culture. So, Animals are used in Japanese Tales because they have a strong tie to the Japanese culture and its outside influences. If I were to ask someone of a popular

The Use of Animals in Research

808 words - 3 pages In March 1980, there emerged a group called PETA, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. This group, founded by Alex Pacheco and Ingrid Newkirk, fights against the use of animals for research. PETA became a well known name between 1981 and 1990 when they went up against IBR, Institute for Behavioral Research. In the book Monkey Business, the story is told of the ten year battle between PETA and IBR. “Through it all, the Silver Spring

Use of Animals in Biomedical Research

2235 words - 9 pages Use of Animals in Biomedical Research": Patterns of conduct are not the issue. Animals do indeed exhibit remarkable behavior at times. Condition, fear, instinct, and intelligence all contribute to species survival. Membership in a community of moral agents nevertheless remains impossible for them. Actors subject to moral judgments must be capable of grasping the generality of an ethical premise in a practical syllogism. Humans act immorally

Of Animals And Wars

577 words - 2 pages Of Animals and Wars Someone called Man a social animal. Noting one of the most characteristic behaviors of animals being aggression, add a couple of billion wild animals to this equation and give them brains. The results vary.Looking through our past and counting infinitesimal wars, I think we have fought each other almost to extinction. Nations went asunder in terms of policy and conflict resulted. Through the ages, war has made us, and at the

Similar Essays

Use And Misuse Of Opioid Replacement Therapy In France

1342 words - 5 pages gender was predominant (three men for one woman) and mean age was 34 years at initiation of ORT. HDB remained predominant among reimbursed ORT; however, the part of methadone steadily increases from 20% in 2006 to 32.5% in 2012. These results on patient characteristics and evolution of methadone use confirm recent published data [1, 12, 13]. One of the objectives of the study was to evaluate the risk of misuse through some warning criteria such as

Sappho’s Reception: Use And Misuse Of Her Work

2682 words - 11 pages centuries. Catullus, Ovid, Swinburne, Tennyson, Baudelaire, Donne, Pound, and others have used Sappho’s fragments and biography in their own work. One of the reoccurring questions raised in critical discussion has to do with this handling of Sappho’s work by men who misappropriate her poems. Do they misuse her female and homoerotic themes for their own masculine voices and ideas? To answer these questions I will look closely at the specific times

Sappho's Reception: Use And Misuse Of Her Work

2612 words - 11 pages diminish her as a feminine writer in a feminine-prevalent society. Either way these scholars made prevalent the notion of Sappho’s work as abnormal feminine psychology at its most disturbing. Mary Lefkowitz argues that Sappho’s poetry shows a sophisticated and ingenious use of traditional poetic figures and literary topoi in her essay “Critical Stereotypes and the Poetry of Sappho.” Lefkowitz does a close reading of Sappho’s Fragment 31 in an

The Use And Misuse Of Power In Ancient Times

788 words - 4 pages was shown by a true concern for the people. The Palace was open and there to do the peoples business. They earned respect through good acts, and that builds power. Three very different ways to achieve power. Presented are three very different society power stories. We see power expressed in all of these ancient structures. Three very different concepts on how a leader should use his power.