Utopia The Flawed Pursuit For Perfection

1107 words - 5 pages

Perfect societies have long been discussed and debated, prominent in the works of many great philosophers such as Plato and Thomas More. It wasn’t until the 16th century however, that a formal name was to be attributed to this unattainable perfection - a utopia. As a result, utopias and their opposite, dystopias have become prominent in modern works and form the basis for this analysis in William Golding’s The Lord of the Flies and Suzanne Collins’s The Hunger Games. Through their most recognised pieces, Golding and Collins demonstrate that free will and control cannot be moderated effectively to sustain a utopian society. Demonstrating that human greed and corruption dismantle these ideals, effectively creating a dystopia.

Through The Lord of the Flies, Golding demonstrates the degradation of a potentially utopic society, into one that’s heavily characteristic of a dystopia. The downfall of the potentially perfect society within The Lord of the Flies is resultant of the greed and powerlust embodied by the antagonist Jack. Freed from social constructs and an overarching power, the boys are given an opportunity to live freely. Ralph’s government allows for individualism and free will, resulting in the failure of many systems which he tries to implement, such as the signal fire, however his predominant concern with physiological needs including safety and wellbeing creates a positive state on the island. Jack, envious of Ralph's leadership, begins to preoccupy himself with superficial preoccupations such as slaughtering a pig for the dominance and control. Jack then separates from the clan to form his own tribe, promising meat to anyone who joins. Towards the end of the novel, a great disparity is present between Jack and his followers. Through his greed and corruption, he positions himself as a superior being, a god, which is explicitly referred to in the novel “... Jack, painted and garlanded, sat there like an idol. There were piles of meat on green leaves near him, and fruit, and coconut shells full of drink.” (pg 124). Ralph’s leadership, although heavily flawed, aimed to please the masses, and for the most part could be considered utopic. Jack and his totalitarian regime were implemented for his benefit, and although the tribe economically prospered, due to his greed and egocentric personality, the island degenerated into a dystopia for everyone but him.

The Hunger Games presents a nation with two great divides. The Capitol, a plutocratic state, filled with riches and luxuries, and the satellite states that obediently serve it. Governed by President Snow, the citizens of The Capitol for the most part are ignorant, but they are content due to their high living standards and blind ignorance which is recurringly highlighted through Iffy Trinket and her recognisable saying ‘’May the odds be ever in your favour!’. In order to prevent uprising, the districts are segregated, poor and living in fear, barring them both physically and...

Find Another Essay On Utopia - The Flawed Pursuit for Perfection

Pursuit for the Meaning of Life

779 words - 3 pages . In the second poem, however, images drawn from the speaker's experience with the pastoral world is everywhere. It is not easy to distinguish reality from dream. Since the speaker is for the most time in the state of unconsciousness .If we see the" apple-picking" as accomplishment and success or pursuit for the meaning of life, then obviously it is sweet at some point ,but the author also thinks it as "too much" . He recalls the details of the

The Pursuit for Preservation - Environmental Paper

947 words - 4 pages The Pursuit for PreservationSome sixty-five million years ago, just after the demise of the dinosaurs, a small rat-like species of mammal (now known as a prosimian) left the ground and took to life in the trees. Eventually after fifty million years had passed, this creature returned to the ground as the ancestor of man. The period spent in the environment of the trees was of great formative importance because it promoted many physical changes

Aylmer's Struggle for Perfection in Nathaniel Hawthome's, The Birthmark

2052 words - 8 pages birthmark at any price. Perfection is a goal he must attain and he uses " ... science as a means to those absolutes to which [he] is totally devoted" (Rucker 45 1), perfection and scientific achievement. Georgianna's love of Almer intertwines with his love of science to bring strength to Aylmer's pursuit of perfection. Thus Georgianna, in conjunction with the birthmark, conspires in her own death by sacrificing herself for Aylmer's science

Starve for Perfection, the Cost of Anorexia Nervosa

1603 words - 6 pages Starve for Perfection, the Cost of Anorexia Nervosa There are innumerable amounts of people in this modern society that suffer from eating disorders. Forcing to be part of a society were it is more significant to be thinner than healthier and fitter, the media perpetuates and feeds over the strong feelings that women have to be thin to be desirable. With the media purporting the standards of what a beautiful woman should look like to get into

The Aria of War: Justifications for the Pursuit of National Security at Any Price

1715 words - 7 pages “asymmetrical warfare” and “war on terror” were used liberally by an executive branch wholly unprepared for mitigating such a threat, and exploited to justify any number of means to achieve an end that as yet remains elusive. With the threat now subsiding, and certain means of statecraft and defense now thrust into the harsh light of public scrutiny, we are faced with questions of worth. Specifically, have the measures utilized in pursuit of

The Pursuit of Survivial in Exchange for Happiness in Charles Dicken´s David Copperfield

3365 words - 14 pages The Pursuit of Survival in Exchange For Happiness in Charles Dickens's David Copperfield: In Charles Dickens's David Copperfield, there are many lower class citizens who are treated with disdain and even disinterest by every social class that is above them. While the novel is clearly a social commentary on the treatment of the poor in 19th century London, the characters in the novel do very little to remove themselves from their downtrodden

Jane Eyre: The Pursuit for Identity in Victorian Society

1777 words - 8 pages According to the Merriam Webster Dictionary, identity is “the qualities, beliefs, etc., that make a particular person or group different from others”. While relatively simple to define, finding one’s identity in a world that seems vast and incomprehensible proves difficult for many, and for some, impossible. The process of self-discovery is a long and arduous journey undertaken only by those of the strongest character. Charlotte Brontë’s, Jane

The pursuit of the reformation was not so much about altruistic motive of saving people's soul as it was about the quest for power

759 words - 3 pages This statement is true, and can be seen in the reformation in Europe started by Martin Luther. The main issues of this case are the rise of Protestantism trying to take over Catholicism, the use of the Printing Press as a form of propaganda, and avenues of power and corruption within the movement. All of these led to a movement in terms of trying to dethrone Catholicism, but in the end became covetous and only wanted power for its own gain.The

"Utopia: An Interaction Between Social Idealism and Realism"

3574 words - 14 pages More showed the urgent need for reform in England by presenting the contrast between the social handicaps of English society and the radical perfection of Utopia. Through this critique of England, More was able to show how wicked men have become and that change was required.In addition to the ideas of Andrews, the beliefs of Charles J. Erasmus also pertain to the critical nature of utopias in general. In his 1977 book In Search of the Common Good

Utopia America

1079 words - 4 pages The thought of a utopia, where everyone is exactly the same, must appeal to some in need, such as the homeless and the poor. Those people would think that their lives would be better with the transition of our society. However, this is the wrong move to make and we should stay with our current, even if flawed form of government. The first point I have to make is the high cost that we must pay to move to such a point. America, for example has

UTOPİAS

590 words - 2 pages Fantasy is important for the writers of utopias because the vision of reality is almost necessarily idealized or demonic. To put across the intensity and significance of either, the author departs from the dullness of everyday, and that can be done with fantasy. Since the creation of Earth, manhood searched the earth for the reasons of life and the pursuit of tranquality roaming the planet looking for personal answers to the questions that have

Similar Essays

The Goal Of Flawed Perfection Essay

1353 words - 5 pages comparing and contrasting his characters such as Bottom, Titania, Helena, and Demetrius to mythical stories from the ancient times. Through various examples of flawed divinity and celebrated mortals, Shakespeare elevates the capacity for human potential so that every individual may relate and strive for perfection of the flawed divine.

Utopia The Impossibility Of Perfection

1669 words - 7 pages Utopia - The Impossibility of Perfection "The latter end of [this] commonwealth forgets the beginning." ?William Shakespeare, The Tempest From Plato's The Republic to Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto, the search for a perfect social state has never stopped; its ultimate goal of achieving a human society that exists in absolute harmony with all due social justice, however, has proved to be woefully elusive. The pure concept of a utopia

The Mistakes In Searching For Perfection

820 words - 4 pages deformities would cause humanity to work together peacefully, while eliminating things like jealousy, greed, and embarrassment. But, they are overlooking the gloomy effects that come with perfection. We should stop searching for the perfect person because it leads to conflict, points out the imperfections in people, and perfection is impossible to achieve. Searching for the perfect person would not be beneficial because it leads to conflict. Some people

Land For The Free: A Flawed Justice System

2516 words - 11 pages Historically there is no doubt that the United States justice system is flawed. The same lawmakers who freed themselves from the hands of Britain turned around and belittle mankind based off of skin color. It is very hypocritical that Americans demanded freedom from the British, nonetheless enslaved people for over three hundred years. The United States justice system continues to fail its people, it is continued for too long and it is now the