Western Feminism Is Promoting Colonialism In The Third World

1678 words - 7 pages

Chandra Mohanty argues in her essay “Under Western Eyes: Feminist Scholarship and Colonial Discourses” that many Western feminists write about women in the Third World as if they were a homogenous mass. She argues in her essay that the Western feminists need to see the variety among women in the Third World. While at times she falls into the same generalization trap that she accuses the Western women of making, she ultimately proves that the feminist believe that Third World societies oppress all women elevates the Western world view as the superior one again and is similar to the colonialism of previous times.
Mohanty writes that feminists in the US and western Europe act similarly towards women in the Third World. She asserts, “The definition of colonization…is…focusing on certain mode of appropriation and codification of ‘scholarship’ and ‘knowledge’ about women in the third world…as they have been articulated in the US and western Europe” (Mohanty 694). Invoking the word colonization connects everybody in the US and western Europe with the historical and still prevalent belief that Eurocentrism is the predominantly superior culture. She makes the claim saying that colonization still interests the West. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, colonization’s definition is, “The action of colonizing or fact of being colonized; establishment of a colony or colonies”; or “To settle (a country) with colonists; to plant or establish a colony in” (“colonization”). Feminism seeks “Advocacy of equality of the sexes and the establishment of the political, social, and economic rights of the female sex” (“feminism”). Mohanty’s statement that the Western feminists seek to settle their perceived knowledge over women in the Third World would therefore be in contradiction to the goal of equality. After all, if the feminists push their preconceived opinion onto Third World women, since they generalize the whole region, they are not establishing equal rights, but place their Western preconceived notions on the women, and in extension on the men, as well. However, Mohanty falls in the same mode of thinking, since no general truth encompasses all of Western thinking, under which she summarizes feminism.
Western feminism thinks that all people of Third World countries are alike and the mainly white female feminists of all places try to prove this using similar research. In order to prove that white feminists generalize people of different races and cultures, Mohanty writes, “I would like to draw attention to the remarkably similar effects of various analytical categories and even strategies which codify their relationship to the Other in implicitly hierarchical terms” (Mohanty 694). “The Other” are a group or a people who are outside of one self’s circle and are usually marginalized and seen as different from oneself. Mohanty uses “The Other” to speak about the women in the Third Word, but she also includes “working-class and feminist women of color...

Find Another Essay On Western Feminism is Promoting Colonialism in the Third World

Growth in the Third World Essay

1863 words - 7 pages more atomic bombs in their own country alone, than all other countries have detonated bombs, combined. The US, similar to most countries in the world, has always had the constant necessity to discover and harness new forms of power. The problem is that their desire to be more powerful has come at the cost of nature and the people inhabiting it. Between 1946 and 1954, three nuclear bombs were detonated by the US in the area of the Marshall Islands

The Invisible Revolution in the Third World

1864 words - 8 pages caused corruption to flawlessly growing. This made Peru to become a third world corrupted state. Since the Peruvian mercantilism continue to decline. Obviously, it is impossible that it will regain social relevance and that the situation will not continue to deteriorate. In 1985, new government took office, “the minister of the interior informed Parliament that there had been 282 land invasions in Peru so far that year, 153 of which had

Government Corruption in the Third World

1326 words - 6 pages People in third world country’s suffer under the hands of their corrupt leaders things like this happen in the united states, but they are not as noticeable as they are elsewhere. In third world countries like Syria, there is a lot of injustice in many things especially in the government. In certain instances, they call themselves a democracy and don't let their people vote in important decisions. Government corruption is a huge problem that

Women In Third World

1457 words - 6 pages In March 1947 the House of Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) came to Hollywood to expose communist influence in the film industry. HUAC was invited to Los Angeles in 1947 by the Motion Picture Alliance for the Preservation of American Ideals, an organization whose motto was "co-existence is a myth and neutrality is impossible…anyone who is not fighting Communism is HELPING Communism." By 1951, HUAC had obtained more then 300 names

The Devastating Power of Western Colonialism

2153 words - 9 pages . During the nineteenth century, a significant gap started to emerge between the dominant Western powers an the rest of the world (Marks). The effects of this gap, built in large part on circumstance and chance can still be seen to this day. The long term impacts of western colonialism extend far beyond the boundaries of the newly industrialized societies, helping build the foundation for western peri-industrial imperialist culture. The causes for

The world banks role in developing third world countries

702 words - 3 pages to are internationally criticised for environmental destruction. But the raising of interest rate repayments has forced third world countries to develop quickly, and many have taken to producing cheap goods in large quantities and distributing them to an international market filled with consumers. Even by western standards these products are often sold cheaply, the money that a producer makes is rarely distributed fairly to his workers, and the

Developing the Third World

2218 words - 9 pages Promoting the development of the ‘Third World’ is a constant goal of the United Nations and other enterprises aiming to promote equality amongst humankind. However to promote development, the issue of mass poverty must first be addressed. Poverty is a constant problem, which exists in various levels and forms within our society and the world. At the current poverty threshold of $1.25 a day, the Word Bank estimates that around 25%, of the

Feeding The Third World

4101 words - 16 pages Feeding The Third World Millions of people today, despite technological advances enabling fish and meat production and crop yields to soar, are still living in hunger. It is estimated that nearly 30% of the world's population suffer from some form of malnutrition, and the majority of these people live in Developing Countries. Intensive and Subsistence Farming both present possible solutions to dealing with world hunger

What is the role of imagination in “The Playboy of Western World”?

1104 words - 5 pages Imagination according to Oxford English Dictionary is defined as “the mind's creativity and resourcefulness to invent images which have the tendency to form ideas which do not correspond to reality.” In “The Playboy of Western World” by John Millington Synge, the presence of imagination directs the outcome of the play. Synge uses Christy as a substitution to the existence of boredom, fear and insecurity. Christy gave a remark “I did not then

North America Causes Poverty in the Third World

1413 words - 6 pages understand. We work hard, we go to school, we get jobs, we live our lives, and now we’re being told that simply living the way we do is, well, criminal. That really sucks, huh? It’s not like we wake up each morning with this plan, this ultimate goal, “Hey, I’m going to vacuum up the lives our Third World pals so I can live the coolest life ever!” Oh no, we really are nice people – but selfishness works in sneaky ways. It’s the very governments

urbanization in third world countries

1284 words - 5 pages countries then they are called radical nationalists (from class discussion) they are stripped of all of their power by a far superior military then theirs, governments are replaced by better more core friendly people (examples- the Belgian Congo in the 1960s, Panama and Teddy Roosevelt). In order to make the people in third world countries something more than low-wage slave labor, something must change. I believe that the problem is forced

Similar Essays

Contemporary Western Critique In Third World Cinema

2269 words - 9 pages addition, both Peck and Chadha remained in Europe afterwards, having between them lived (and still do) in England, France and United States. It is just this First/Third World biographical juxtaposition and perspective, both evident in these filmmakers’ personal lives and in their work, that places them within the sphere of Third Cinema. Ella Shohat, too, recognizes this new outcome of a merged Western/Third World genre of film in her assertion

The Problem With Western Perspectives On Child Labour In Third World Countries

1355 words - 6 pages The problem with viewing child labour in third world countries Exploitative labour has been a problem worthy of concern since the industrial revolution, more so with the ongoing human rights and equality movements around the world. Some may argue that it is the equivalent of modern slavery, others such as Karl Marx attributes exploitation as a by-product of capitalism. Exploitative labour is not slavery but it does contain some qualities thereof

Third World Country In Comparison With Western Style Economy

4654 words - 19 pages Third World Country in Comparison with Western Style EconomyWith an overall comparison of Australia and Vietnam's economic structure through economic systems, economic indicators, fiscal and monetary policies, and international trade, Australia is a more efficient economy than Vietnam's economy. Australia is more free-market then Vietnam when analysing their political economic structure based on political economic spectrum, economic system, and

Conflicts In The Third World Essay

1372 words - 5 pages forget that ethnicity is also a major player in conflict in third world nations. Rwanda is an example of this. Ethnic violence was at its highest during the 1990s. As the London Observer stated in 1998-SEP, "Most global conflict can be blamed on a basic imbalance: mankind is made up of 5,000 ethnic groups with only 190 countries to live in." Ethnic tension, between groups known as the Hutu and Tutsi group, has been going on for over a hundred