"Whistle Blowing" Essay

2162 words - 9 pages

Whistle blowing refers to the act of organisation members, either former or current, disclosing information on illegal and unethical practices within the organisation to parties internal or external to the organisation, who can take action. It is becoming increasingly common as more and more employees speak out about their ethical concerns. It cannot be denied that whistleblowing is accompanied by a range of problems, for both the whistleblower and the organisation. However, it can be argued that whistleblowing is an important and valid method of endeavoring to control possible unethical behaviour by organisations, as well as helping to establish a level of social responsibility. For these ...view middle of the document...

Nevertheless, obligations of confidentiality and loyalty ideally should not take precedence over the fundamental duty to act in a manner that prevents unnecessary harm to others.While these are all valid concerns, it is important for a whistleblower to concentrate on the positive aspects that reporting the wrongdoing can have. The CJC (1999, p. 32) states in its report that "over time, whistleblowing will increasingly be regarded as a normal workplace responsibility". When a whistleblower exposes the corrupt deeds of an organisation, they are not only acting ethically and responsibly, they are also serving to encourage those same qualities throughout the community. Other obvious benefits resulting from blowing the whistle include putting an end to the wrongdoing and those being disadvantaged by the wrongdoing, bringing to justice the individuals or organisation accountable for the wrongdoing, avoiding potential damage to the health and safety of the community, stopping potential damage to the environment, and creating an opportunity to implement improved internal practices in order to prevent wrongdoing in the future (CJC 1999, p. 2).Any potential whistleblower must realise that a well thought-out approach is both essential and practical. Firstly, be positive the situation is one that warrants whistle blowing. Secondly, carefully examine the motives behind the whistleblowing in order to ensure that they are genuine and can serve the public interest. Next, verify and document all information, as this will help to add further credence and strength to disclosures (CJC 1999, p. 13). Fourth, determine to whom the wrongdoing should be reported, and if the internal or external route is best. The allegations should then be stated in a clear, concise and objective manner. Lastly, ensure that all appropriate guidelines have been followed in reporting the wrongdoing. Coyne (2003) recommends consulting a well-informed lawyer in order to help a whistleblower determine the best course of action to take, as well as what protection is available to the whistleblower. The CJC (1999, p. 36) recommends that in order to sufficiently prepare themselves, potential whistleblowers need to understand that they may be unfairly vilified.There are many occurrences where whistleblowing has deflected considerable harm towards society. One such example illustrated by Jennings (2003), is that of Jerome J. LiCari, a former director of research and development for Beech-Nut Nutrition Corporation. Due to the low cost of the apple product used in most of the organisation's fruit foods, Mr. LiCari suspected the apple product to be a chemical substitute. His concern prompted him to tour the supplier's facilities, where he found only a warehouse. Mr. LiCari reported his findings internally to the organisation's Purchasing Manager and Vice President of Operations, neither of whom took any action in the matter. However, Mr. LiCari would not be discouraged, and eventually determined that...

Find Another Essay On "Whistle-Blowing"

Problems Faced by Whistle-blowers Essay

2481 words - 10 pages With an aid of appropriate examples, discuss the problems that a whistle-blower is likely to have to consider in deciding whether or not to speak out. Whistle blowing is an attempt by a former or current employee of an organization to disclose illegality or any other wrongdoing in or by an organization. Whistle blowing can be divided into two types namely, internal and external whistle-blowing. When wrongdoing is reported to someone with a

Whistleblowing Essay

2012 words - 9 pages Whistle blowing is the act of reporting a business or organization that is doing something that would potentially harm the public. People expect organizations to do ethical practices and should have public safety at the center of all of its practices and concerns. These practices include making products. These products that are made for the public and should be one-hundred percent safe to use. The problem of whistle blowing is that some

State and Federal Systems

981 words - 4 pages Abstract:This paper will discuss the similarities and the discrepancy between federal and state employment protection laws pertaining to whistle blowing. This paper will provide an overview of what whistle blowing is and the issues related to differences between state and federal regulations.State and Federal Systems Paper.Employment laws exist as a bridge between companies and employees so that each receives equitable consideration when it

This essay is about whislteblowing in the Canadian Government. It gives the good the bad and the ugly about whistleblowing

1236 words - 5 pages The matter of whether or not to provide protection to whistle blowers in Canadian Government Organizations has been discussed for many years. However, to date, there has not been a bill passed to give whistle blowers full protection.Whistle blowing is defined as "an act of a man or woman who, believing that the public interest overrides the interest of the organization he serves, blows the whistle that the organization is involved in corrupt

Whistle Blowers

1099 words - 4 pages duties as a citizen. He was just trying to protect the children (citizens) from death leading operations that had already killed 29 babies and children. Stephen actions on this issue only show us his dedications and love for society, because he put both his family and career at risk only to save the society. As a whistle blower, Stephen Bolsin knew that the benefits of blowing the whistle far outweigh the cost just like Charles Grassley.As a farmer

Biography of Edward Joseph Snowden

1215 words - 5 pages America. According to Dennis Thompson, administrative ethics portrays that the administrator should either follow the rules of the organization ore resign if he is not satisfied with those policies. So according to this statement, it is clear that snowden should have resigned and should have never blown the whistle. According to me, I think Edward Snowden has did the right thing by blowing the whistle. He was not able to live with himself at the

The Business Software Alliance

885 words - 4 pages unlicensed software following an investigation by the a whistle-blower. The company was required to conduct a self-audit, which revealed unlicensed adobe, auto desk and Microsoft software. Reason for Whistle- Blowing The Bsa's online from for reporting software piracy anonymously is relatively straight for ward: along with name, address, size of the informant, industry sector, name of ceo and

The Treatment of Whistleblowers

2056 words - 8 pages studies in this area support the notion that thing have gone awry. First, we shall look at the concept of whistleblowers Whistleblowers often make their way into the public eye, but what is a whistle blower exactly? What are the criteria? Whistle blowing is "raising the alarm in public about a wrong being committed in private" (Vickers, 2002, p.42). By definition, a whistle blower can only "blow the whistle" on an organization of which he is a

Whistleblowing and Corporate Ethics: Hughes Aircraft

1057 words - 4 pages , Goodearl and Aldred were extremely affected and treated unfairly, so much so that " [Goodearl] and her husband had to file for bankruptcy, and Aldred was on welfare for a year before she could find another job."(The Hughes Whistleblowing Case , n.d.). Hence, the main focus of this paper is to determine whether or not whistle blowing is really worth the trouble, even though it is almost always ethically correct. What are Goodearl’s obligations

Employment-At-Will

1023 words - 5 pages Bill using the company-issued Blackberry to run his own business is unacceptable. This is not implying the act of good faith and dealing for the company and the employment-at-will is enforced. Sometimes Whistleblowers can create a negative type of behavior and employees may not be aware of these rational motives. There is a thin-line between the employee’s level of public service to be used for encourage of whistle-blowing behavior or

Ethics in Business

3130 words - 13 pages Whistle BlowingWhat is it?One major difficulty surrounding the issue of whistle blowing is the definition of it. Many attempts have been made and several differ slightly. One example is made by Michelle Allen in which she states in her internet article, "Whistle Blowing" that "Whistle Blowing is when someone tells the truth about misconduct by an individual or company that is against the law or more importantly endanger the lives of others." I

Similar Essays

Whistle Blowing Essay

1072 words - 4 pages -blowingwhistle blowing. However, in the definition of whistle-blowingwhistle blowing, the act of whistle blowing should be undertaken as a moral protest; the motive must be to correct some wrong and not to seek revenge or personal advancement. Therefore, ifSo in the case that Herbert’s motive wais to seek revenge, then the act will not be considereda genuine whistle blowing at all.

Whistle Blowing In Auditing Essay

2426 words - 10 pages Question 1 Introduction At the start of this century, unprecedented collapses of Enron and WorldCom have sparked heated world discussions over corporate whistle-blowing. In light of this, legislations and professional codes of conduct are implemented to provide framework on ethical and financial decision-making particularly for auditors. This essay covers prerequisites for an effective corporate whistle-blower hotline, measures to avoid

Does Blowing The Whistle Violate Company Loyalty?

813 words - 4 pages Does Blowing the Whistle Violate Company Loyalty?Employees have moral obligations to respect the property of the corporation, to abide by employment" onmouseover="window.status = 'goto: employment';return 1" onmouseout="window.status=''">employment contracts, and to operate within the bounds of the company's procedural rules. However, the duty of loyalty is not absolute. That an employee should be loyal is a prima facie duty. The object of

Organizational Justice For Whistle Blowing And Harassment In The Public Personnel Sector

1814 words - 7 pages than social technology. While some interventions may be less successful on some occasions or in particular contexts, none is likely to be harmful, and at the very least they will promote a sense the organization is concerned about fairness. Conflict between administrative efficiency and individual rights can result perceptions about an organizational justice procedures. Despite whistle blowing and sexual harassment are largely two separate bodies