Why Are Utopias “Imaginary”? Essay

1080 words - 5 pages

A place where everything is perfect, where there are no troubles, where everybody wants to live: these are the things we immediately associate with a utopia. But what really characterizes this divine paradise? A utopia is defined by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary as “an imaginary place in which the government, laws, and social conditions are perfect.”
The social conditions of a utopia entail that every single organism holds a position within the society that he desires. Could this ever be achieved with a class system? No. One could never covet others’ social statuses if the population was socially undivided. George Orwell’s Animal Farm epitomizes this very condition. By removing the two class structure—humans and animals—the Manor Farm is transformed into a utopia. Each and every animal on the farm is regarded to be equal. There was no more human tyranny, but instead a communal and democratic society where one animal had just as much social influence as the next. Libria, depicted in Kurt Wimmer’s film, Equilibrium, is yet another example of the elimination of a hierarchy. People dressed in the same clothes, lived in the same houses, and felt the same things. There was no variation, just a single class: human. This seems simple, but how could this ever be preserved?
Equality of this level could not be maintained without the proper rules to stop disparity before it emerges. Look around. What is stopping your neighbour from killing you? Laws that stop murder are as essential to our current society as laws that stop divergence in a utopia. When the Animal Farm was saved from the destitute Manor Farm, the seven commandments were developed to stop one animal from being superior to the next or from resembling a human:
1. Whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy.
2. Whatever goes upon four legs, or haw wings, is a friend.
3. No animal shall wear clothes.
4. No animal shall sleep in a bed.
5. No animal shall drink alcohol.
6. No animal shall kill any other animal.
7. All animals are equal. (15)
In Libria, laws against deviating from the emotional equilibrium suppressed individuals’ needs to assert their dominance over others by eliminating contempt. But what good are these laws without anyone to enforce them?
The government in a utopia differs from that of one familiar to us. Instead of simply causing a raucous, the government is held to the same strict standards as the citizens are held to. This creates a governing body that wants to improve life in the utopia for the citizens simply because they are citizens as well. On the Animal Farm, the pigs are elected to create order in their society: “With their superior knowledge it was natural that [the pigs] should assume the leadership” (17). The pigs were able to create systems that saw no animal treated differently from another, including the pigs themselves. In Libria, the government ridded themselves of hate to remove belligerence, just as the pedestrians had. This mutual belief resulted in...

Find Another Essay On Why Are Utopias “Imaginary”?

Utopia Essay

1207 words - 5 pages The idea of a Utopia traces all the way back to when the Pilgrims boarded to Mayflower. They dreamed of creating a “an imaginary place in which the government, laws, and social conditions are perfect” (Merriam-Webster). Since then there have been many attempts at creating a Utopia. Some have failed and some have succeeded. Examples of two well-known attempts at a Utopia are Jonestown and the Oneida community. They both had convincing and

Utopian Societies Essay

1147 words - 5 pages Republic was the model for many utopian stories. Written utopias can have many themes, such as humanistic, practical, religious, and secular, that present solutions for existing conditions. They tend to focus on liberty and extoll living a simple life. Many are satires that mock existing conditions rather than suggesting workable solutions. Gulliver’s Travels (1726) is an example of a satirical utopia story (More’s Utopia, 2013). More’s Utopia

There is no Universal Utopia

1601 words - 6 pages what a utopia is. From Plato's republic in 380BC right up to the modern day, literally hundreds of books have been written, and movies made, all which give differing opinions on what is the perfect world. It is impossible for one person to try to comprehend what would be the perfect utopia in which every person would be happy, so we must consider that perhaps the utopias written about are not meant for the multitudes, but are only supposed to

Comparing Plato's Republic, More's Utopia, and Gurney's Dinotopia

1513 words - 6 pages Gurney's Dinotopia, three imaginary societies are described, each with its own peculiarities and highlights. Various aspects of the nations described in these three novels, including their respective economies, governments, and social structures, will be compared and contrasted. A crucial aspect of any society would be its economy. In Utopia, business was conducted chiefly to import iron, and in many cases they traded on credit. The

Utopias of 21st Century

9963 words - 40 pages used to evaluate the three types of Utopias which can be found in feminist literature, and which are labeled as "end-state," "anarchist," and "process" Utopias. In brief, researchers argue that the Utopian thinking we need must involve attainable yet flexible goals that include a Deweyan concern for democratic practices and for the education necessary to increase broad participation in critical decision-making processes. (Dewey, 42)The first (and

Types of Utopias

1001 words - 5 pages possible” (Mastin). Interestingly enough, there are significant differences between Utopia and The Republic. According to More, key components of a perfect society consists of a minimal governmental control, a strong family unit, no private property or currency, and a six-hour work day. But Plato’s ideal republic materializes very differently. In regards to religion, utopias are somewhat ambiguous. In general, either exclusive or inclusive religious

The Importance of Narrative Scripts through Being John Malkovich

997 words - 4 pages ” world, or the Symbolic, where everything is seemingly off or strange. His apartment is filled with animals; the office where he works is on the 7 ½ floor, situated between the 7th and 8th floors with low ceilings; the people that he is surrounded by are all a little off, but perceive themselves as normal. When he enters into the portal, he once again enters into the Imaginary, finding that he prefers the stability and order of the Imaginary to

Comparing Margaret Cavendish’s The Description of a New World, Called the Blazing World and Sir Tho

1803 words - 7 pages perfect society. Judging one from one’s physical beauty should not occur either, but in Utopia, the brides and grooms-to-be are paraded in front of one another in the nude, so to protect them from “deception beforehand” (More 516). Aside from the union of husband and wife, family and community structures are also crucial in the utopias of More and Cavendish, and these structures are closely regulated by their respective governments

The Matrix vs The Minority Report

2081 words - 9 pages ), but in reality are stood still and motionless Utopia gone bad. Concluding again we spoke of this, in how a dystopia is an imaginary world, usually a futuristic society, where a make believe utopia (as seen as The Matrix vs. The Real World) occurring due to a totalitarian regime. Moving now on to Minority Report we see many differences and similarities to The Matrix, but first digging into its context as a whole, for it is a unique film of its own


10057 words - 40 pages human. This aggressiveness showed that everything was going to become out of hand. -Each day these boys are in fear of the imaginary beast lurking the island, and this fear blurs their actualvision like when Sam and Eric saw the paratrooper, and with all the talk about a beast, the thought that it was the beast itself. After, Jack found a way to manipulate this fear, to be used for his own advantage, to bring neutrals to his side. -When Ralph

What do we mean by 'Radicalism', in feminism?

986 words - 4 pages turned to activism through the above-mentioned methods. It was truly an era where the people’s voices were going to be heard and if there was no platform for the voice of the people who represented the ‘oppressed’ section of society to express their discontent, then radicalism was going to be the answer.Many people became hostile to the idea of the state controlling their everyday life and began asking questions such as: Why should

Similar Essays

A Better Life Feature Article: Utopia

584 words - 2 pages The literal meaning of Utopia is actually “no place” or “place that does not exist”. Utopia is the perfect; ideal but unattainable place that everyone strives towards to. This imaginary place has the ideal civilisation and society.There is a utopia in every one’s hearts. A lot of people are dissatisfied with their lot in their life. They feel that there is a utopia that once reached will instantly grant them happiness

Literary Utopian Societies Essay

1715 words - 7 pages person had a chance of leaving his caste, and his conditioning had programmed his mind into believing that this was all acceptable (66). When looking at utopian literature as a whole, one realizes that utopias are merely a way that man uses to improve himself and the environment in which he lives (Eurich 7). The purpose of texts written about utopian societies is to inform the public of current social problems and to inform them how to fix these

"Utopia: An Interaction Between Social Idealism And Realism"

3574 words - 14 pages reality an ideal society or Utopia. From this, we can draw out that although utopia is an ideal kind of society, it is utterly unreal for utopias cannot exist in a world full of unrest. In this paper, I presented a variety of ideas on Utopia by famous writers and philosophers. This includes the realistic and idealistic points of utopia and why it can never come true. I emphasize on the irony that utopia aspires people to strive for a better society and

"The Beach By Alex Garland, And "" The Lord Of The Flies" By William Golding

603 words - 3 pages adopt a homogenous ideology.The action of phasing out difference favours a somewhat sterile community where all opinions are identical to avoid an imbalance within the society. J.Carey wrote in 'The Faber Book of Utopias' "The aim of all utopias, to a greater or lesser extent, is to eliminate real people even if it is not a conscious aim; it is an inevitable reslt of their good intentions. In a utopia real people cannot exist, for the very obvious