Workers Vs. Protesters Essay

1509 words - 7 pages

Workers vs. Protesters
On January 15, 2014 the US Supreme Court took on the case of the abortion protester and the Massachusetts law. The court had considered abolishing the buffer zone around abortion clinics because it violates the first amendment for the protesters. As the court still debating over the buffer zone law, many authors have raised their voices on the issues. Emily Bazelon and Amanda Marcotte have different views on the buffer zones for abortion protesters. Amanda Marcotte’s article is focused on the point of view from the abortion clinic workers while Emily Bazelon’s article focusing on the point of view of the abortion protesters. However, Amanda Marcotte’s article has a stronger argument because her article contains more valid reasons to uphold the buffer zone.
Amanda Marcotte’s article “Abortion Clinic Workers on Why the Supreme Court Should Uphold Buffer Zone” is mainly about clinic workers and their reason why the court should uphold the buffer zone. Her article starts off with the background of the story and then the author moves on to talk about the abortion clinic workers' concerns. Like the title of her article suggests, her main point is to showcase the three clinic workers experience with the anti-abortion protesters. Their names are Michelle Kinsey Burns, Lori Gregory Garrott, and Megan. The clinic workers’ personal experiences are what makes Marcotte’s argument valid to uphold the buffer zone law.
Michelle Kinsey Burns, Lori Gregory Garrott, and a counselor's name Megan all have bad experiences with the anti-abortion protesters in the buffer zone. According to the article, these clinic works have faced hostile protesters each day when they come to work. Even though, the hostile protesters have never used physical confrontation to these workers, but the protesters’ presence around the buffer zone combine with the screaming and yelling can make them feel threatened. This threatening feeling from the protesters is also felt by patients who coming to the clinic. The protesters screaming and yelling are more than enough to make anyone who comes to the clinic feel that violence is going to break out any time soon.
Near the end of her article, Amanda gives one last reason for the reader to consider upholding the current buffer zone law. She talks about the case at the Planned Parenthood’s Brookline Facility in 1994. In this case a clinic worker name Shannon Lowney was murdered because she was the receptionist who just opened the clinic door every morning. After murdering Shanon the culprit, John Salvi, traveled to another clinic and killed two more abortion clinic worker before being captured. This is case that help push the lawmaker to pass the buffer zone law back in 2007.
Emily Bazelon’s article “You Do Not Have the Right to Be Left Alone” is focused on the buffer zone law from the protesters’ point of view. She argues for the protesters to have more freedom when they are near an abortion clinic. The article starts off...

Find Another Essay On Workers vs. Protesters

Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Memorandum

1568 words - 6 pages , 2005). As it will briefly outline the simulation in week three involved a breach of contract dispute between Gentura and CadMex Pharma. I will also outline three examples of laws conflicting with cultural practices in their companies today.The dispute between Gentura and CadMex Pharma should be settled by international arbitration vs. Candore Courts. International arbitration is a proceeding in which two public or private entities refer their

Martin Luther King Essay

1283 words - 5 pages face of death and the intention was finally achieved through democracy and the legal system with this particular protest demonstrating all three of Kings philosophies. The events of Birmingham in 1963 would later demonstrate the effectiveness of peaceful protest in portraying a battle of good vs. Evil. In this demonstration protesters were set on by dogs and were hit by powerful fire hoses yet they showed no reaction

The Emergence of Yellow Power

2287 words - 9 pages charged a small fine. The conclusion was declared as a hate crime, which caused an uproar amongst the Asian community and escalated into a civil rights case. The public outrage incited many who were afraid to voice their opinions and led to an uprising. Similarly, in Sei Fujii Vs. California, an immigrant bought land, but had it confiscated because he was not a legal citizen. The state did not compensate with his money and many protesters claimed

African American History

2235 words - 9 pages the South. By the mid-19th century, a large number of slaves worked in urban areas as well, and about 5% worked in more industrial occupations. The hours of the slave workers were long. The average life expectancy of African slaves was at least 12% lower than whit Americans in 1850 and the infant mortality rate was 25% higher for slaves. Oftentimes slave marriages and families dissolved due to separation. This concept is horrible when you

Antiglobalization

2206 words - 9 pages nature, including protests, boycotts, demonstrations, and working through nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). For others, opposition takes on a decidedly more active, even violent form. Benjamin Barber's famous book Jihad vs. McWorld noted this diversity of forms, using jihad, the Arabic expression for holy war, as a metaphor for the vast umbrella of groups opposed to contemporary globalization and "McWorld" as a metaphor for the American-led

The Effect of War on American Civil Rights

2437 words - 10 pages With the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the racial segregation that was previously a major feature of American life, most notably in the South, was outlawed. This came after a lengthy civil rights movement that began in the 1950s, featuring contributions from activists as well as an overall change in the psyche of the American populace. However, the movement has its origins prior to the infamous Supreme Court ruling in Brown vs. Board of Education or

Bleeding Ireland and Black America

4509 words - 18 pages Sixteenth Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama. In1964, SNNCand much of the youth of America are unable to agree on which ideology to follow: directaction or revolutionary politics. Three civil-rights workers are murdered that year leadingto a more violent opposition by protesters. On July 2, president Johnson signs the CivilRights Act of 1964.Malcolm X is murdered Feb. 21, 1965. On August 6. President Johnson signs theVoting Rights Act

Should Abortions Be Legal ?

1923 words - 8 pages regulated it to back alley butchers, when abortion was illegal is was the leading killer of pregnant women in US. Pro choice protesters agree that an unwanted pregnancy will produce an unwanted child. Feminists insist the value of an unborn boy or girl it to be determined by whether a woman wants him or her. To use being wanted by someone as a measure of whether a human life is allowed to live is a frightening concept. Its converse logically

African American History

2074 words - 9 pages ruling in The Griggs vs. Duke Power Co case, for instance, eliminated key barriers to black employment by declaring “tests and other requirements unnecessary for the performance of a job” discriminatory (White et. al. 2012). With the premise of employment now placed solely on employer racial attitudes, the number of hired black workers increased by the second half of the 1970s. In his 1986 case on the affirmative action debate, American law

Integrating Business Values: The Legality, Morality, And Social Responsibility Of A Woman Who Uses RU 486 To Terminate Pregnancy

7325 words - 30 pages access to legal abortion fail the strict scrutiny test and are therefore invalidated or struck down" (prochoice.org).FREEDOM OF ACCESS TO CLINIC ENTRANCES ACTThe Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act (FACE), was passed by the United States Congress in 1994. This measure was designed to protect abortion patients and clinic workers from disruptive, anti-choice protesters at clinics. This has been valuable in stopping anti-choice violence outside of

Global Recession

9707 words - 39 pages gives rise to unemployment rate because companies/businesses lay off their workers to cut more costs, as consumer spend less. These factors combined, manage to drive the economy into a state of recession.In February 2008, Reuters reported that global inflation was at historic levels, and that domestic inflation was at 10-20 year highs for many nations. "Excess money supply around the globe, monetary easing by the Fed to tame financial crisis

Similar Essays

Researcj Essay

2539 words - 11 pages the public. In an 1877 sermon, preacher Henry Ward Beecher summarized the opinion of many Americans: "I do not say that a dollar a day is enough to support a working man… But a man who cannot live on bread and water is not fit to live." Beecher and many others believed workers must submit to whatever conditions prevailed in the industry. Despite the 1842 Supreme Court ruling Commonwealth vs. Hunt, which established that unions were technically

Hate Speech On College Campuses

563 words - 2 pages impossible to write an anti-speechcode that cannot be twisted against speech nobody means to bar. Free speech rightsare indivisible. Restricting the speech of one group or individual jeopardizeseveryone's rights because the same laws or regulations used to silence bigots can beused to silence you. Conversely, laws that defend free speech for bigots can be used todefend the rights of civil rights workers, anti-war protesters, lesbian and gay

China's Way To Condemn Western Political Model: The Tianamen Incident

1884 words - 8 pages 1. Introduction The following paper focuses on the Tiananmen Incident and the China’s way to condemn Western political model in its aftermath by describing and applying the Asian values. Even though protesters were demanding only anti-corruption officials and more economic transparency West defines the issue as people were demanding the democracy and more political rights. While Chinese officials were suppressing the issue very harsh, Western

Censorship We Must Not Restrict Speech

554 words - 2 pages rights are indivisible.  Restricting the speech of one group or individual jeopardizes everyone's rights because the same laws or regulations used to silence bigots can be used to silence you.  Conversely, laws that defend free speech for bigots can be used to defend the rights of civil rights workers, anti-war protesters, lesbian and gay activists and others fighting for justice.         &nbsp